TV REVIEW:
The Joe Schmo Show
Spike TV's is willing to put any
wacky! show idea on the air. This leads to some very bad programming. Most Extreme Elimination Challenge is so dumb I don't know how anyone could watch it. Ren & Stimpy's Adult Party Cartoon is too gross for the tastes of anyone I know or would like to know. Gary the Rat is like a half hour test pattern. A few of the things they air actually work. Stripperella is funny when it's not trying to hard to be sexy. Slamball is a well thought out sport.
The Joe Schmo show is another
wacky! idea. The producers create a parody of a reality TV show; It's a copy of Survivor set in a mansion called Lap of Luxury. All of the contestants on the show are actors except one. Matt Gould. Law school drop out, pizza delivery guy. Not a rocket scientist. He doesn't know that he's the only real contestant and that the whole show is scripted around him.
The fake contestants are stereotypes so broad I can describe them in one word. Jerk, Buddy, Slut, Quack, Virgin, Gay, Schemer, Veteran. Some of the acting here is pretty bad, especially the scheming Survivor fan Gina. Especially hammy is Ralph Garmon as the host. His over the top performance may be the funniest scripted element of the show.
The entertainment from reality shows comes from reality, tautologically. The reality of watch real people react to odd situations. Condensed down to the most entertaining moments, of course. The more real the reaction the more we feel for the show. When people who act like they just walked out of central casting try really hard to be cool the show fails, as is the case with Dog Eat Dog. Because most of the contestants on Joe Schmo did just walk out of central casting, the entire burden of the show is on Matt to unwittingly deliver the reality.
It's hard to imagine the producers finding a better mark than Matt. He's game, willing to jump though every silly hoop on the show. He's also a generally good guy, making it easy to root for him. And he's not smart enough to realize how stupid everything going on around him is. It doesn't matter that the acting is awful because he buys into everything going on around him. The actors slip up and can't keep their stories straight and he doesn't notice. He should be especially suspicious of all the interest the beautiful women of the show have for him.
Matt's reactions to the situations around him are priceless. He's not a complete puppet. He nearly gives the actors and producers a heart attack when he voluntarily loses the game "Hands on a Hooker." Yet for the most part, he's finding every trail of cookie crumbs left for him. The writing is pure cheese and filled with holes; Matt finds away to fill them up. Three Stars, solely on Matt's "performance."